M4L Title IX Lawsuit

HUGE WIN FOR MOMS FOR LIBERTY

Moms for Liberty’s historic federal lawsuit against the Department of Education (DOE) challenging the Biden administration’s rewrite of Title IX regulations led to a federal district court issuing a landmark preliminary injunction prohibiting the DOE from enforcing these changes in several states and at the schools attended by the children of members of Moms for Liberty.

It is important to understand that this injunction is preliminary in nature, meaning that unless an appellate court rules differently in the future, it will remain in effect until the district court can fully hear the case. It is currently under appeal. This Title IX litigation will likely continue for many months because challenges will continue to be filed and then appealed through the legal system by parties on both sides of the fight. 

Ultimately, the issues surrounding the Biden Administration’s Title IX rewrite, which is blatantly unconstitutional and unlawful, will most likely be decided by the United States Supreme Court sometime in the next year.

 

 

Lawsuit - Filed 14 May 2024

Initial lawsuit filed with a US District Court in Kansas. Plaintiffs include Moms for Liberty, Young America’s Foundation, Female Athletes United, Minor K.R, and the states of Kansas, Alaska, Utah, & Wyoming.

2 July 2024 Ruling

Ruling by US District Court granting injunctive relief to the plaintiff states and also members of the plaintiff organizations, including Moms for Liberty.

19 July 2024 Ruling

Clarifies prior ruling that injunctive relief is granted to all current and future members of plaintiff organizations, including Moms for Liberty, thus removing any time limit to join.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ON TITLE IX LITIGATION
Updated August 28, 2024

The district court stated that the Department of Education cannot implement or enforce its new Title IX regulations in any school attended by a child of a Moms for Liberty member. But because Moms for Liberty does not publish information on where its members children attend school, the district court told Moms for Liberty to submit a list of schools to put the Department of Education on notice that it cannot enforce or implement the Title re-write at those schools. This essentially created an opt-in system, allowing Moms for Liberty to submit a list of schools that its member’s children attend and to update that list on a continued basis. The list will not identify members by name, it will only list the schools.

Current Moms for Liberty members need to go through their “member portal” and click the link that says “Edit Profile” to opt into a list of schools that can be protected from Title IX implementation. This link is connected to a NEW list of US public schools that members can use to select their child’s school. If not already a member of Moms for Liberty, follow the link titled “Join the Fight” to sign up as a member and then continue to the opt-in to list to select the child’s school. 

Detailed instructions of how to opt-in and ensure that Moms for Liberty can inform the district court that your child’s school is covered by the injunction can be found at momsforliberty.org/title9/. If you do not see your US public school on the list in the member portal, please email Moms for Liberty at [email protected].

No. The preliminary injunction prohibits the Department of Education from implementing or enforcing the Title IX rewrite at all schools attended by children of current and future Moms for Liberty members. Moms for Liberty can and will continue to update the list of schools it provides to the district court unless an appellate court says otherwise.

On July 15, other parties in the lawsuit provided the district court with a list of schools that their members attend, but because Moms for Liberty is organized at the county level it was not able to provide a list of schools at that time and only submitted the schools attended by the children of the four brave Moms for Liberty members who put their name on the lawsuit.

Simultaneously, Moms for Liberty’s attorneys worked through the legal process to ensure maximum protections possible for Moms for Liberty members, ultimately obtaining clarification that the preliminary injunction applies to both current and future members and that it can continuously update the list of schools as needed.

The DOE has asked the appellate court to revisit the inclusion of schools of Moms for Liberty members who joined after July 2, 2024, and Moms for Liberty’s attorneys are diligently defending their inclusion.

Moms for Liberty and its legal team wants the district court’s July 2024 order to apply to as many schools in the US as possible. To that end, the district court is allowing Moms for Liberty to submit (and update on a regular basis) a list of schools that its members’ children attend so that it can notify the DOE that it cannot enforce the Title IX rewrite at those schools. The list of schools will NOT identify Moms for Liberty members by name—it only lists the schools, nothing else.

Historically, Moms for Liberty has never collected information on where members’ children attend school. Because of this, inclusion of a member’s child’s school is completely opt-in and based on a NEW list of US public schools that members can choose from. The only way a school will appear on the list submitted to the district court is if a member logs in to the member portal and updates their member profile to include school information, or if a current non-member joins Moms for Liberty as a member and provides school information.

Members of Moms for Liberty and their families are heroes in standing up for the rights of their children, but in doing so they have become subject to harassment, threats, and intimidation. Moms for Liberty is committed to protecting the security and personal identifying information of its members while still availing them of this important legal victory. The organization and its legal team continue to work to make sure that this order can be applied in a safe, secure way.

For purposes of the district court’s preliminary injunction, it does not matter what type of Moms for Liberty member you are.

Moms for Liberty encourages ALL prospective members to begin the process of becoming a chapter regular member. This membership has many benefits, far beyond anything connected to the potential outcome of litigation. Chapter regular membership is the best value to anyone interested in joining the organization.

Once a list of member schools is submitted to the district court putting the district court and DOE on notice that those schools are covered by the injunction and included in the court’s protection from implementation of the Title IX rewrite, those lists will all be available on this webpage (linked below) and with the lawsuit’s key legal filings at https://www.slfliberty.org/case/moms-for-liberty-and-young-americas-foundation-et-al-v-u-s-department-of-education/.

Note: These legal filings are submitted periodically and not in real time. Members can contact their chapter chair for additional questions about their child’s school.

It is important to know that individual schools will not be notified by the district court or Moms for Liberty that the DOE can’t enforce its Title IX rewrite against it. It is not known currently if the DOE itself will notify schools or post a list of schools.

Parents can always choose to directly notify a child’s school and/or school district that it is covered by the preliminary injunction by providing it with a copy of the notice Moms for Liberty files with the district court. (The lawsuit’s key legal filings are available at https://www.slfliberty.org/case/moms-for-liberty-and-young-americas-foundation-et-al-v-u-s-department-of-education/.)

If a school board questions whether or not a parent is a Moms for Liberty member, that parent can show the school board their membership confirmation email.

In its preliminary injunction opinion, the district court found the Title IX rewrite violates Moms for Liberty members’ children’s First Amendment rights because it is so vague and overbroad that no one knows how to comply with it.

Even the DOE itself admitted during oral argument that it didn’t know when students could be punished for speaking out against gender ideology or advocating for their safety in private spaces. Instead, the DOE said “let’s wait and see” — but the district court didn’t buy that approach.

If the government itself can’t even say when its rule applies, no one should be forced to comply with it. Moms for Liberty believes this is a huge win for parents across the country and for our American republic.

This is a valid concern shared by many parents across the country. There two important things all parents can and should be doing to stop radical gender ideology from taking hold in their child’s school:

First, read up on the law. Learn more about the Title IX rewrite and why it and policies similar to it are unlawful and unconstitutional by scheduling a webinar for a Moms for Liberty chapter with Southeastern Legal Foundation by emailing [email protected].

Second, educate a local school board on the law by providing it with copies of the preliminary injunction order  and the district court’s clarification of the preliminary injunction order in this lawsuit which provides strong legal reasoning and precedent, explaining why these policies are unlawful and unconstitutional.

Links to Lists of Schools Submitted to the District Court 

First Notice to DOE of Schools with Plaintiff Organizations’ Members (July 15, 2024)

Second Notice to DOE of Schools with Plaintiff Organizations’ Members (July 26, 2024)

Third Notice to DOE of Schools with Plaintiff Organizations’ Members (July 31, 2024)

Fourth Notice to DOE of Schools with Plaintiff Organizations’ Members (Aug. 28, 2024)

CURRENT MEMBERS

Learn how to add your child’s school to your profile

NEW MEMBERS

Become a member of Moms for Liberty for FREE today!

Catalina Stubbe

Director of Hispanic Outreach

Catalina is a successful mother of four, rooted in her love of God and family. She is always advocating for the wellbeing of children. She has been featured on Fox & Friends with Kayleigh McEnany, War Room with Steve Bannon, Linea De Fuego (Univision) and more. She is a Colombian American businesswoman, journalist, philanthropist, strategy adviser, contributor and commentator, and humble servant to the Lord.

Pat Blackburn

National Director of Chapters

Pat is a retired educator and mom. She envisions a public school system in America that is reflective of the principles of freedom granted by our Creator. “God has called me, and equipped me, to do my part in service to Him and our country.”

Rosalind Hanson

Director of Development

Rosalind is the Mom to a joyful son, and like most parents, the pandemic afforded her a peek behind the classroom door. As Moms for Liberty’s Director of Development, Rosalind ensures our donors are kept up to date on our work, which is made possible by their generous financial support and the efforts of our over 130,000 volunteer members.

Tia Bess

Director of National Engagement

Tia is a mom of three with a blended family. Bess resides with her partner on a farm in Clay County, FL. She has been a member of Moms for Liberty since March 2021 when the pandemic led her to voice concerns regarding her children’s school in her district. Bess was born in Philadelphia, PA but left for Norfolk, VA at the age of seven due to gang violence in the area. Shortly after the move to Virginia, her family moved to Jacksonville, FL where she learned that her zip code didn’t define her, a message she hopes to spread to America.